The Yankees need to address their rotation after Clarke Schmidt went down with what’s expected to be Tommy John surgery. He’ll miss all of 2025 and likely part of 2026.
That’s where Joe Ryan comes in.
The Minnesota Twins right-hander has caught plenty of attention around the league, and MLB analyst James Nolan from FanSided thinks the Yankees should make a move for him.
“Joe Ryan has been dominant for the Minnesota Twins this season,” Nolan wrote. “He’ll be one of the most coveted pitchers at the deadline because of his ability and team control. He won’t hit free agency til 2028.”
“The Twins starter would likely require a lucrative package to acquire, considering all the factors. Cashman would likely have to include Jones, along with other top prospects. At this point, with all the injuries, the Yankees would be foolish not to put together something to trade for Ryan.”
Ryan’s control situation is what makes this interesting. He’s just 29 years old and locked up through 2027, which explains why Minnesota would want a hefty return. But that’s also exactly what makes him valuable to a Yankees team that needs reliable playoff starters.
The numbers back up the interest. Ryan’s 8-4 with a 2.76 ERA in 18 games this season, including 17 starts. His 0.89 WHIP shows the kind of command that translates well in October.
It’s not just this year, either. Over his MLB career, he’s 41-30 with a 3.71 ERA – solid production that’s only gotten better recently.
The price tag would likely include Spencer Jones, one of the Yankees’ top prospects, plus additional pieces. That’s not cheap, but with Schmidt’s injury timeline and the team’s championship window, it might be necessary.
From where I’m sitting, Ryan gives them exactly what they need – a proven starter who can handle big moments and won’t be going anywhere for a few years. The way the rotation has been hit with injuries, they can’t really afford to wait and see what develops internally.
All things considered, it’s the kind of move that could define their season.
