The Blue Jays might become sellers at the trade deadline if their slow start continues, with Daulton Varsho emerging as a prime trade candidate according to ESPN’s Buster Olney.
Olney believes this year’s outfield trade market will be particularly thin, setting up a scenario where Toronto’s front office could be flooded with calls about their defensive star. It’s a classic supply-and-demand situation that could work in the Jays’ favor.
“The would-be opportunists could take advantage of a really soft outfield market and get value if they’re willing to dangle outfielders under team control beyond this season,” Olney wrote. “For example, the Twins could set a solid price for Buxton, and the Jays would probably draw a lot of interest for Daulton Varsho, an elite defender who won’t be eligible for free agency until after the 2026 season.”
What makes Varsho especially attractive is his contract situation. He’s making $8.6 million this season with another year of club control remaining. That’s the kind of team-friendly deal that contenders covet, especially for a player with his defensive credentials.
The timing could be perfect for a trade. With the upcoming free agent outfield class looking weak beyond Kyle Tucker, teams might be more willing to part with significant prospects to land a proven defender like Varsho.
But here’s where it gets interesting. The Jays aren’t necessarily out of contention yet. They’re sitting just one game back of a Wild Card spot, which complicates any potential selling decisions. The front office might prefer to hold onto Varsho, viewing him as a key piece for both an immediate playoff push and their 2026 plans.
Varsho’s Gold Glove-caliber defense remains his calling card, though his offensive production has been limited this season. He’s hitting just .194 with 3 home runs and 7 RBIs in 31 at-bats after missing time with an injury to start the year.
The next few weeks will likely determine Toronto’s deadline approach. If they climb into a playoff position, expect them to hold onto Varsho. If they fall further back, he could become one of the most sought-after outfielders on the market.
